Sideways

The soundtrack, composed for Sideways by one of my favorite contemporary composers, Rolfe Kent, has been one I've loved for years, know by heart and can't get enough of. This wonderful jazz-scented music is playful, melancholic, sensitive, funny... Essentially, it uses almost all existing moods and always feels suitable. Well, after today, it's clear that the film is in terms of having the same mood. A pleasantly truthful spectacle, definitely not moralizing, definitely not explosively funny and, despite the two-hour runtime, it’s also not too long. A sunny film, in which it does rain a few times, but what can you do? When it rains, you should wait for the sun to shine again, right? Superbly acted, filmed and, of course, also scored. However, I can't help it, I liked A Good Year better. (10/19/2013)

As a marketing tool, the Oscar Award is ideal, but as the ultimate measure of film quality, it is definitely not. Sideways had the potential to outshine precisely executed but overly ambitious projects like The Aviator and the award-winning Million Dollar Baby. This was the film that had the power to make that universally accepted standard of quality fall into its hands. But it was too small, fundamentally too ordinary, and at first glance, it went, quite fittingly to its name, too sideways. The screenwriting duo of Alexander Payne and Jim Taylor took the most stereotypical route to the theme of a bachelor party. The move, which is not at all abnormal in a time when there is nothing else to do but revamp the old and give it a stamp of novelty and originality, is slightly risky from Payne and Taylor, but it paid off many times over. At least those two won an Oscar for it. Perhaps it was the desire of the screenwriters to cram something new, unconventional, and especially atypical into the film, or a deliberately aimed symbol in which the tragicomic fate of the film's characters could be reflected. Wine, for an American, is probably as natural a drink as Kentucky whiskey is for a Frenchman. And yet, in the film, wine tasting seems perfectly natural, as if it were an everyday affair for every American. It smells pleasant, a little sour to taste, then comes the sharp taste of alcohol, and when you drink too much, it can give you a headache. "In vino veritas" and Sideways is like the wine. The long search for love, and yet it's not a romance, plenty of humorous situations, and yet it's not a comedy. Besides good ideas, Sideways also respectfully borrows from every genre a certain amount of perspective, from which you can see just enough for a happy-looking ending, depending on who you ask, it must be added. Moreover, "Payne the director" is a completely different person than "Payne the writer." He carefully avoids all the pitfalls of the genres from which he respectfully borrowed and doesn't burden the viewer with conversational boredom or indulge in jumping from one gag to another, and heaven forbid, playing on a romantic string. Payne sticks to everything in moderation, but not in an awkward way. Also, all established Hollywood stars should respectfully kneel in front of the performances delivered by the central quartet in this film. And for Thomas Haden Church to lose in an Oscar race to a standard-issue Morgan Freeman? He really didn't deserve that. Sideways not winning (I deliberately don't want to use the word "losing") the Oscar may not be the harshest crime of the Academy, but it will definitely take me a while to accept it. (06/21/2005)

Sideways certainly doesn't belong to the kind of films that immediately captivate every viewer and appeal to all movie fans indiscriminately. It's a subtle yet charming conversational piece, an ordinary film about average people experiencing a midlife crisis. No one should expect a barrage of iconic lines or a flood of zany gags. It's a film about searching for love and friendship, built on an intelligent script and strong performances by quality actors. Virginia Madsen, in particular, stands out in the role of the waitress Maya. Overall impression: 75%. (05/27/2007)

Sideways is a very, very nice little film that doesn’t pretend to be artsy and, despite all of its sophistication, it doesn’t shy away from vulgar and dry humour. You’ll get to know the pair of lead characters on such a personal level that they’ll become your friends. And you’ll experience so many comical and sad real-life moments with them that you’ll leave the cinema more satisfied than after any other film far and wide. I was pleasantly surprised by the level of humor, which elicited belly laughs in the last stage (the wallet). It’s regrettable that the Academy ignored Paul Giamatti’s brilliant performance. I’m giving Sideways a similarly strong four stars as in the case of And Your Mother Too. (02/10/2005)

A peculiar mix of life's moments that, to a greater or lesser extent, will be encountered by the vast majority of us. Giamatti in top form and probably in the best role of his career, Haden Church for a change in his only proper (big) role, if we don't count the bland villain from the big-budget Spiderman. Payne mixes just the right amount of comedy, a moderate amount of fucks, and the perfect amount of wine that will leave the viewer tipsy but not so drunk that they won't like it anymore. In places, the overlong running time bothers just a little, and the delivery of some of the actors, with the exception of Giamatti, isn’t quite perfect. Between 3 and 4 stars. A pretty successful tasting. (09/28/2022)