I'm with Lucy

Dumped by the man she thought was perfect for her, newly-single Lucy (Monica Potter) continues her search for Mr. Right. Set up on a series of blind dates, she meets five handsome and eligible bachelors, each with his own charms... and flaws. There's the macho jock (Gael Garcia Bernal), the handsome surgeon (David Boreanaz), the divorced writer (John Hannah) and the uptight executive (Henry Thomas). Has she finally met the man of her dreams or will her dating nightmare never end? (official distributor synopsis)