Toman

If I hadn't read a book about the Slánský trial last week, I would have given "only" four stars. Now that I know all the high-ranking officials (paradoxically, the only character who was unfamiliar to me was the protagonist), it makes the story even more relatable. I found the film really interesting with all the manipulations and intrigue of an organization that devoured its members like Saturn his children. Plus, the creators also managed to create a perfectly bleak atmosphere. (05/02/2019)

This ambitious project about a man who did business with everyone after World War II and helped bring about the Communist takeover unfortunately tries too hard to be true to reality at the expense of entertainment. Two and a half hours is really too much, especially when there's not much interesting stuff going on most of the time, and it's repetitive to boot. The excellent final quarter shows that this could have been not only the story of a not very well known but important man, but a really good, entertaining and engaging film. (10/04/2018)

I had to get used to Jiří Macháček, because, especially from the beginning of the film, he spoke every now and then in a style that would fit more into a parody, but I got used to it and I'm glad. Toman entertained me thanks to him, and thanks to the amazing Kateřina Winterová, in a way that I would have liked if the film had continued for a few dozen more minutes. It was only in the end that things began to happen that I did not expect. It's admittedly well shot until then, but (whether you know something about the real Toman or not) it’s actually quite a predictable story that resembles a film version of Czech Century (and I mean that as compliment). (11/21/2020)

Though Toman is a high-quality work in terms of production (cast, staging, period atmosphere), it is interesting only for quite a restricted audience, among which I do not belong. The main character’s personal life outlines the narrative, but 90% of it is devoted to chattering and plotting among politicians. I did not enjoy it despite the historical significance of the events depicted, the decent character portrayals and the interesting, dazzling mosaic of diverse political beliefs, motivations and moral values. (11/17/2018)

Aren’t there too many of these political period dramas? Right? There was A Prominent Patient, Dubček, quite recently Rašín and currently Toman, for a change. This person was, I admit, unfamiliar to me. I was expecting an espionage thriller, so something that isn’t completely common in our country. Well, I partially got it. The film really radiates great quality. After all, Ondřej Trojan isn’t a director who would leave the filming of his ideas up to chance. Quite the opposite. Rather, I had a problem with the fact that the first half of the film is too historically factual and at the same time very little film-like. The film-like quality appears only about after 2 thirds of the movie, where I really started to get excited by the dynamic character of the movie and at the same time, I had to admit that the historical factuality has its place here. I think it’s really hard to make a movie based on history and explaining the historical context in a way that would make sense. Here, the movie sacrificed its first half to it, but it was justified in the end. After the film, my friend and I talked and wondered whether Toman was a good person. That’s a question every viewer probably has to answer on their own. In truth, we didn’t figure it out. The only thing that really got to us were the actions of the communist party after the year 1945 and consequently in 1948. I am not going to spoil anything, but I felt really sick. Toman thus definitely deserves the attention it is getting. I just feel like it will have something to say mainly to us and the Slovaks and it won’t catch on in Europe. Well… I might be wrong. (10/19/2018)