Dark Phoenix

The revelry continues with hollow material from which absolutely nothing can be milked, even if Fassbender and co. were standing on their heads. The X-Men are long past their sell-by date for many reasons. A story that’s too convoluted, the time jumping, the clichéd scripts. This episode not a hit with a tight grip. The last really good episode thus remains First Class, which was fresh, original and with extremely skilled direction, the other films have been a mess. Maybe standalone spin-offs have a chance, but this bunch is otherwise way past its prime. (09/07/2019)

Jean Grey has become the Dark Phoenix, and the other X-Men can't tame her the easy way. But do they stand a chance against their former partners? And what if someone far more dangerous is after her new powers? The new X-Men return to their roots and try to rely on interesting characters and character development more than action. It succeeds only halfway. Unfortunately, Simon Kinberg's surprisingly solid direction is tripped up by the often not-so-good actors and an overly rushed story. There are some strong emotional moments, though, and the finale on the train is among the best action we've ever seen in X-Men. I was expecting a lot worse. (06/06/2019)

The fact is that this movie was supposed to be a magnificent end to the entire X-Men saga. However, it is more like a slow and sleepy piece that fizzes out as an empty exercise. Entrusting the final movie of the series to a skilled screenwriter but completely inexperienced director Simon Kinberg probably reaped its own reward. Without any exaggeration, it could not be duller and more tired if it tried. This is a movie that will leave you completely indifferent and with the feeling you have been robbed. (02/03/2020)

Compared to First Class and Days of Future Past, X-Men: Dark Phoenix doesn't have much to surprise and doesn't offer a very deeply thought out story with twists and turns. Unfortunately, Sophie Turner failed to convince me that she is a powerful "Dark Phoenix" even after this film. Almost all of the young actors there seemed more like sidekicks, and I was somewhat uncomfortable with the rapid swings in their mindsets. The character with the face of the demonic Jessica Chastain appealed to me the most. On the other hand, I have to commend the final sequence on the train, which was packed with action from floor to ceiling. It's nowhere near the old and first new X-Men, but it could have been worse. (06/09/2019)

The X-Men are back where they started, and Dark Phoenix is a great film mainly because, like Singer's first two films, it cares so much about the characters. Once again, dialogue and emotion play a primary role, and the action scenes serve mainly as a spectacular journey leading to the very thing that once set the mutant saga apart from other comic book movies and made it a grown-up spectacle with room for reflection. If the Dark Phoenix script had been written and filmed in 2006 instead of Last Stand, it would have been an amazing conclusion to the trilogy. As it is, it's an amazing conclusion to a somewhat disjointed and confused saga that, while it has somewhat lost itself over time, has always managed to find itself again. In terms of the acting, I have nothing to fault, of course from the story I'd like to acknowledge the errant Professor X, as well as Jean herself, and director Simon Kinberg pleased me as much as the screenwriter – now I'm not just talking about the divine train finale, but especially the pervasive tension and justifiable sense of doom that he manages to evoke (thanks in part to Zimmer's music). (06/11/2019)