Knockin' on Heaven's Door

German film = bullshit. For many years, this equation was the first thing that popped into my mind whenever someone mentioned the cinema of our western neighbours. But then I heard about this film, saw its high rating and I watched it full of expectations. Well, I’m speechless! All the praise that has been mentioned and rehashed so many times in the reviews here is doubly true. The amazingly unique and groundbreaking direction, the precise combination of black humour and a hackneyed detective plot, and the very honest and detailed portrayal of the two main characters, a bit in the style of Jarmusch, make this crazy and unconventional "last party" one of the best European films of the last decade. (01/31/2013)

A gleeful copy of everything that was cool back then in the East. Gangsters, male bonding, rock soundtracks à la Tarantino, copying Western formal practices, and the sheer license to make fun of everything, no matter what the level of fun it happens to be. Some of the stuff from that era still feels fresh, some you're glad it's gone. (06/27/2022)

It is indeed a masterpiece of German cinema and the success of the film meant a significant revival in the German film industry of the 90s. I can't claim that I didn't like it - after all, 4 stars indicate that it entertained me at the time, but I still get the feeling that it is somewhat overrated. One positive aspect is the combination of dying with black humor and a positive effort to make the most of every minute of one's life. On the other hand, the humor, which has its great moments, fluctuates and there are also awkward moments, especially toward the end, when Rutger Hauer appears. Then there's the topic itself, which can be considered calculated, which may not be true but also cannot be refuted. Of course, there are much worse versions of tear-jerking sentimental films, so I wouldn't blame Knockin' on Heaven's Door for that. However, I do believe that Thomas Jahn is not a talented director, as his whole career ultimately shows, and he only managed to match the tastes and expectations of the audience in one case. Overall impression: 70%. (04/14/2009)

Another beautiful example of how German and European cinematography is interesting. It does not shy away from challenging topics, but at the same time, it presents them in such a way that it simply must inspire or at least touch you. No exaggerated pathos, a beautiful drama with elements of comedy, and both aspects work. Americans are also trying to do this, but only at an independent level. Well, Europe is still ahead in some respects. (03/11/2014)